« Apple's results might be great, but coverage of Apple results is disappointing | Main | Hold the front page »

October 22, 2008

AppleInsider's coverage of Apple versus RIM is wrong

AppleInsider.

"Apple announced quarterly iPhone sales that surpassed those of BlackBerry maker Research in Motion by nearly a million and a half units or 25%: nearly 6.9 million iPhones versus 5.4 million BlackBerry units in the third calendar quarter of 2008." (My emphasis)

It's amazing how many inaccuracies you can cram into a single sentence. This one manages two, which render the entire thing worthless.

First RIM hasn't reported results for the third calendar quarter - its quarters don't match up to calendar quarters, being out by a month. Its last report, on the 25th September, covers the three months ended 30th August.

Secondly, it didn't report sales of 5.4 million BlackBerry devices. As Steve Jobs noted, during that quarter it reported sales of 6.1 million. "Prince McLean" has picked up the results for the previous quarter (RIM's first of fiscal 2009).

One sentence, two simple errors, and a misleading report which is now propagating across the Internet.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341e366353ef010535ae398d970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference AppleInsider's coverage of Apple versus RIM is wrong:

My Photo

Where I'll be...